OhioJunkyards Report a correction

Guide

What used auto parts cost at Ohio pull-a-part yards

Pull-a-part prices in Ohio, November 2026: a used alternator costs $22.99 to $39.00, a starter $22.99 to $36.00 and a steel wheel $11.99 to $26.00 at the state's self-service yards, before core deposits and any tax or fees the yard adds (lists checked November 15, 2026).

Updated Nov 16, 2026.

Pull-a-part price comparison by chain

"How much do parts at car junkyards cost?" a Columbus driver asked on r/Columbus on June 16, 2025. The table below answers it for the parts people pull most, with the refundable core deposit after the plus sign.

Self-service yards price by the part, not by the car. Pull-A-Part charges the same for a part whatever the make, model or year, and every list here works the same way: one price per part type, with separate truck and van prices on some bigger parts. Each column is one Ohio list:

  • Pick-n-Pull: the Columbus yard (Columbus junkyards). Car prices.
  • LKQ Pick Your Part: Cincinnati and Dayton, which share one list. Prices exclude tax and environmental fees.
  • U Pull R Parts: Toledo (Toledo junkyards). Prices include a 6% environmental fee.
  • Youngstown U-Pull-It: 1300 Albert St., Youngstown (Youngstown junkyards). Undated list.
  • Just Junk It: Zanesville, outside the eight metro areas. Free admission.

Pull-A-Part's four Ohio stores have no column this month because its price list did not load (more below).

PartPick-n-PullLKQ Pick Your PartU Pull R PartsYoungstown U-Pull-ItJust Junk It
Alternator$32.99 + $9.99 core$39 + $10 core$34.02 + $5 core$22.99 + $6.25 core$35
Starter$30.99 + $9.99 core$36 + $10 core$28.10 + $3 core$22.99 + $6.25 core$35
Headlight assembly$34.99$45.50$38.46$32.99$25
Door (front)$87.99 + $8.99 core$82.50 + $10 core$65.06$68.99 + $3.99 core$75
Wheel, aluminum$36.99 + $14.99 core$39 + $15 core$25.87 + $25 coreNot on this list$45
Wheel, steel$23.99 + $0.99 core$26 + $1 core$25.87$11.99 + $2.99 core$25
Battery (used)$37.99 + $12.99 core$39 + $12 core$41.20 + $10 core$29.99 + $10 core$35
Engine$399.99 + $64.99 core$299.99 + $75 core$199 + $35 core$160.99 + $50 core$225 + $50 core
Radiator$69.99 + $9.99 core$46 + $13 core$54.71 + $5 core$48.99 + $6.50 core$40
Side mirror$26.99$34$25.33$16.99$25
Tail light$29.99$34.50$28.85$25.99$25
Transmission$254.99 + $29.99 core$174.99 + $30 core$116.82 + $25 core$125.99 + $25 core$225 + $50 core

Posted prices for parts you pull yourself. A core deposit comes back when you return the old part. Tax and fees depend on the yard (see each list's note). Prices change; check the yard's own list before you go.

  • Pick-n-Pull: undated list, read Nov 15, 2026. Car prices (Pick-n-Pull lists separate PU/VAN prices for some parts). Core deposit listed separately.
  • LKQ Pick Your Part: undated list, read Nov 15, 2026. Price excludes tax and environmental fees; refundable core deposit listed separately; optional 90-day guarantee shown by PYP as an add-on.
  • U Pull R Parts: undated list, read Nov 15, 2026. One flat price list for U Pull R Parts' Toledo and Minnesota yards. Page note: prices include a 6% environmental fee. Core price listed separately.
  • Youngstown U-Pull-It: undated list, read Nov 15, 2026. Undated flat price list (columns: part, price, basis, core charge). No aluminum wheel line on the list.
  • Just Junk It: undated list, read Nov 15, 2026. U-pull price list; flat price per part.

Prices from each yard's own price list, read Nov 15, 2026. How we collect this.

Cheapest yard for each part

The lowest and highest price for each part across the four lists in Ohio's metro areas: Pick-n-Pull, Pick Your Part, U Pull R Parts and Youngstown U-Pull-It. Three patterns stand out:

  • Youngstown U-Pull-It is cheapest on most small parts: alternators, starters, headlights, steel wheels, batteries, tail lights and mirrors.
  • U Pull R Parts in Toledo is cheapest on car doors, aluminum wheels and transmissions, and its prices already include its 6% environmental fee.
  • Pick-n-Pull against Pick Your Part: Pick-n-Pull in Columbus is cheaper on alternators, starters, headlights, wheels, batteries, tail lights and mirrors. Pick Your Part in Cincinnati and Dayton is cheaper on doors, radiators, engines and transmissions. Its engine costs $100.00 less ($299.99 against $399.99), though Pick-n-Pull's price is for a complete engine and Pick Your Part's for one without accessories.

No metro has two price lists this month, so the cheapest yard by city is a short answer: Pick-n-Pull in Columbus, Pick Your Part in Dayton, U Pull R Parts in Toledo and Youngstown U-Pull-It in Youngstown. Cincinnati has two self-service chains, Pick Your Part and Pull-A-Part, and only Pick Your Part's prices loaded. In Akron, Canton and Cleveland the self-service chain is Pull-A-Part, whose list did not load.

Lowest and highest price per part, Ohio metro areas, checked November 15, 2026
PartLowestHighest
Alternator$22.99 + $6.25 core (Youngstown U-Pull-It)$39.00 + $10.00 core (Pick Your Part)
Starter$22.99 + $6.25 core (Youngstown U-Pull-It)$36.00 + $10.00 core (Pick Your Part)
Headlight$32.99 (Youngstown U-Pull-It, composite)$45.50 (Pick Your Part)
Front door$65.06 (U Pull R Parts, car door)$87.99 + $8.99 core (Pick-n-Pull)
Steel wheel$11.99 + $2.99 core (Youngstown U-Pull-It)$26.00 + $1.00 core (Pick Your Part)
Aluminum wheel$25.87 + $25.00 core, with tire (U Pull R Parts)$39.00 + $15.00 core (Pick Your Part)
Battery, used$29.99 + $10.00 core (Youngstown U-Pull-It)$41.20 + $10.00 core (U Pull R Parts, side post)
Radiator$46.00 + $13.00 core (Pick Your Part)$69.99 + $9.99 core (Pick-n-Pull)
Engine$160.99 + $50.00 core (Youngstown U-Pull-It, 3 or 4 cylinder, no accessories)$399.99 + $64.99 core (Pick-n-Pull, complete)
Transmission$116.82 + $25.00 core (U Pull R Parts)$254.99 + $29.99 core (Pick-n-Pull)
Tail light$25.99 (Youngstown U-Pull-It, per side)$34.50 (Pick Your Part, quarter-mounted)
Side mirror$16.99 (Youngstown U-Pull-It, manual)$34.00 (Pick Your Part)

Just Junk It in Zanesville, outside the metro areas, charges less for headlights ($25.00), radiators ($40.00) and tail lights ($25.00), and more for aluminum wheels ($45.00). Engine lines include different things, so compare them with care.

Dayton and Cincinnati Pick Your Part: one price list

LKQ Pick Your Part runs one price list at both Ohio yards. All 414 items on the Dayton list carry the same price and core deposit as Cincinnati's (Cincinnati has one extra line at $0.00), and admission is $3 at both. Choose between them by distance and by what is on the lot, not by price. Both yards are on the Dayton and Cincinnati pages.

Pick Your Part's prices exclude tax and environmental fees, so you pay more at the register than the list shows. A Volvo owner on Reddit got a Dayton tailgate quote of list price plus core plus tax in June 2025.

Core charges: the deposit that comes back

A core charge is a deposit on top of the part price. You pay it at the register and get it back when you return your old part. On some parts it changes the cash you need at checkout more than the price does:

  • Aluminum wheel: U Pull R Parts charges $25.87 plus a $25.00 core, so $50.87 at the register and $25.87 once the old wheel goes back. Pick-n-Pull's $36.99 plus a $14.99 core is $51.98 up front.
  • Engine: Pick Your Part adds a $75.00 core to its $299.99 engine, Pick-n-Pull $64.99 to $399.99, U Pull R Parts $35.00 to $199.00. Youngstown U-Pull-It prices engines by cylinder count, from $160.99 for a 3 or 4 cylinder without accessories to $206.99 for an 8 cylinder with them, plus a $50.00 or $55.00 core.
  • Alternator and starter: $9.99 at Pick-n-Pull, $10.00 at Pick Your Part, $6.25 at Youngstown U-Pull-It, and $5.00 (alternator) or $3.00 (starter) at U Pull R Parts. Just Junk It charges no core on either.
  • Battery: $12.99 at Pick-n-Pull, $12.00 at Pick Your Part, $10.00 at U Pull R Parts and Youngstown U-Pull-It.
  • Door: $10.00 at Pick Your Part, $8.99 at Pick-n-Pull, $3.99 at Youngstown U-Pull-It, none at U Pull R Parts.

Keep the receipt, bring the old part in, and ask at the counter how long you have to return it.

Entry fees and the U Pull R Parts 6% fee

Pull-A-Part charges $2 to get in at all four Ohio stores ($1 for its VIP club members). Youngstown U-Pull-It charges $2, LKQ Pick Your Part $3 and U Pull R Parts $3.18. Just Junk It in Zanesville lets you in free. Pick-n-Pull Columbus charges admission but doesn't publish the amount; one Columbus driver paid $2 to go back into the yard in September 2026.

U Pull R Parts builds a 6% environmental fee into its prices. Its gate fee is $3.18, which is $3.00 plus 6%, and an admission punch card is $31.80. Pick Your Part does the opposite and adds tax and environmental fees on top of its prices. So compare like with like: U Pull R Parts' $34.02 alternator already includes the fee, while Pick Your Part's $39.00 alternator does not include tax or the fee.

Age limits differ too. Pull-A-Part, Pick Your Part and Pick-n-Pull let you in at 16. Youngstown U-Pull-It admits only adults 18 and over and has you sign a waiver.

YardGate feeNotes
Pull-A-Part Akron$2 ($1 members)Regular admission $2; VIP Club members $1. Must be 16 to enter. Admission hours: Monday - Sunday: 9:00am - 4:30pm.
Pull-A-Part Canton$2 ($1 members)Regular admission $2; VIP Club members $1. Must be 16 to enter. Admission hours: Monday - Sunday: 9:00am - 4:30pm.
Pull-A-Part Cincinnati (formerly U-Pull-&-Pay)$2 ($1 members)Regular admission $2; VIP Club members $1. Must be 16 to enter. Admission hours: Monday - Sunday: 9:00am - 4:30pm.
Pull-A-Part Cleveland West$2 ($1 members)Regular admission $2; VIP Club members $1. Must be 16 to enter. Admission hours: Monday - Sunday: 9:00am - 4:30pm.
U Pull R Parts - Toledo$3.18Price list line "GATE FEE" $3.18; "ADMISSION PUNCH CARD" $31.8. List says prices include a 6% environmental fee.
Youngstown U-Pull-It$2Yard policies: "A two dollar ($2.00) entry fee applies to ALL who wish to enter"; must sign a waiver; must be at least 18 to enter; last daily admission 4:30. Price list also has "GATE FEE" $2.00.
Pick Your Part - Cincinnati$3Admission: $3. Must be 16 years old to enter.
Pick Your Part - Dayton$3Admission: $3. Must be 16 years old to enter.
Just Junk It$0'Yard Admission is FREE' (site footer). Last yard entrance 4:30 pm.

Gate fees from each yard's location page, read Nov 15, 2026. How we collect this.

Pull-A-Part prices: what we could not get

Pull-A-Part runs four Ohio self-service yards: Akron, Canton, Cleveland West and Cincinnati (the former U-Pull-&-Pay). Its price list loads store by store from a Pull-A-Part web service, and on November 15, 2026 that service did not answer: the store list stayed empty on pullapart.com and upullandpay.com through three tries over about two hours. So this guide has no Pull-A-Part part prices this month.

What we do know: Pull-A-Part charges the same for a part whatever the make, model or year, charges $2 admission ($1 for VIP members) at all four Ohio stores, and sells no catalytic converters at any store. Check its price list on pullapart.com for your store before you go. In Akron, Canton and Cleveland, Pull-A-Part is the self-service chain, so those city pages carry its gate fee but no part prices yet.

Bumpers, fenders and hoods

Body panels aren't in the comparison table, but three Ohio lists price them. Pull-A-Part's bumper price, one of the most asked-for numbers, did not load this month. A Columbus driver worried in September 2026 about what a Civic fender would cost: on these lists a car fender runs $37.95 to $72.99 before any core, whatever the make.

Prices checked November 15, 2026
PartYoungstown U-Pull-ItU Pull R Parts (Toledo)Pick-n-Pull (Columbus)
Bumper$49.99 + $5.00 core (any, bare)$69.50 (bare)$72.99 + $4.99 core (plastic or rubber cover); $96.99 + $4.99 core (complete)
Fender$41.99 + $3.50 core (bare)$37.95 (car); $46.66 (truck or van)$72.99 + $8.99 core
Hood$54.99 + $5.00 core$57.66 (car); $65.06 (truck or van)$77.99 + $8.99 core (without hinges)

Self-service vs full-service prices

This guide compares self-service yards, where you bring the tools and pull the part. We have no full-service parts prices for Ohio to set beside them yet. The self-service junkyard guide covers when it pays to pull a part yourself and what to bring, and the Ohio self-service junkyards list shows the yards that let you pull your own parts.

Price changes since last check

November 2026 is our first month of these lists, so there are no changes to show yet. The next monthly check will show every part whose price or core deposit moved, list by list.

How we collect these prices

We checked every list on November 15, 2026:

  • Pick-n-Pull Columbus: the part list behind the chain's price page.
  • Pick Your Part: the Cincinnati list in full, matched line by line against Dayton.
  • U Pull R Parts: its single price list, which covers Toledo and the chain's two Minnesota yards.
  • Youngstown U-Pull-It: its price page and yard rules.
  • Just Junk It: its u-pull price list.
  • Pull-A-Part: three tries over about two hours; the list did not load.

For each part we take the first matching line, and the car price where a list splits cars from trucks and vans. Lines are not always like for like: an engine is "complete" at Pick-n-Pull, "no accessories" at Pick Your Part, and split by cylinder count at Just Junk It and Youngstown U-Pull-It. The full method is on the methodology page, and Ohio scrap metal prices shows what the same parts bring as scrap.

Related guides

Questions

How much does a bumper cost at Pull-A-Part?

Pull-A-Part's price list did not load on November 15, 2026, so we don't have its number this month. Pull-A-Part charges one price per part whatever the make, model or year, so its list on pullapart.com gives one bumper price per store. Other Ohio yards: Youngstown U-Pull-It charges $49.99 plus a $5.00 core for any bare bumper, U Pull R Parts in Toledo $69.50 for a bare bumper, and Pick-n-Pull Columbus $72.99 plus a $4.99 core for a bumper cover.

How much is a wheel and tire at an Ohio pull-a-part yard?

U Pull R Parts in Toledo sells wheels with the tire on: $25.87 for steel, and $25.87 plus a $25.00 core for aluminum. Pick-n-Pull Columbus charges $23.99 plus a $0.99 core for a steel wheel and $36.99 plus $14.99 for aluminum; Pick Your Part charges $26.00 plus $1.00 and $39.00 plus $15.00. Youngstown U-Pull-It charges $11.99 plus a $2.99 core for a steel wheel and $19.99 for a used tire as-is.

Which Ohio pull-a-part yard is cheapest for an alternator?

Youngstown U-Pull-It, at $22.99 plus a $6.25 core. Next come Pick-n-Pull Columbus ($32.99 plus $9.99), U Pull R Parts in Toledo ($34.02 plus $5.00, fee included), Just Junk It in Zanesville ($35.00) and Pick Your Part in Cincinnati and Dayton ($39.00 plus $10.00, before tax and fees).

Do Ohio junkyards charge to get in?

Most self-service yards do. Pull-A-Part and Youngstown U-Pull-It charge $2, Pick Your Part $3 and U Pull R Parts $3.18. Pick-n-Pull Columbus charges admission but doesn't publish the amount. Just Junk It in Zanesville lets you in free.

How do pull-a-part yards price parts?

By part type. An alternator costs the same whatever car it comes off: Pull-A-Part prices that way, and so do the other Ohio lists, with separate truck and van prices on some bigger parts. Some parts carry a core deposit on top, which you get back when you return your old part.

Can I buy a catalytic converter at an Ohio pull-a-part yard?

No. Pick Your Part and Pull-A-Part sell none at any store, and none of the other Ohio price lists has a converter line.

Are Pick Your Part prices the same in Dayton and Cincinnati?

Yes. All 414 items on the Dayton list matched Cincinnati's price and core deposit on November 15, 2026, and admission is $3 at both.

How old do you have to be to go into a pull-a-part yard in Ohio?

16 at Pull-A-Part, Pick Your Part and Pick-n-Pull Columbus. Youngstown U-Pull-It admits only adults 18 and over.